Cosmos is at a critical juncture, teetering between resurgence and irrelevance. Once hailed as a trailblazer in blockchain innovation, Cosmos now finds itself under intense scrutiny, with its governance and leadership in question. The rise of EVM L2s, roll-ups, and other formidable competitors has fueled whispers that Cosmos has gone from being the vanguard of decentralized technology to a fading star struggling to keep pace with the titans it once inspired. But is this the end of the line, or the moment Cosmos turns the tide? Before writing its obituary, let’s revisit what made Cosmos a revolutionary force and explore how it can shatter expectations, reclaim its crown, and redefine the future of blockchain.
A Unique Vision, but…
Cosmos came to town as a revolutionary. “The internet of blockchains” – IBC, Zones, sovereignty – all that jazz. Each blockchain operating independently, governed by its own rules and tokenomics and yet still benefiting from being part of a larger network. At the time, the tech, the ethos, the promise of the Hub, all seemed ideal compared to the monolithic and rigid structures of the ecosystems like Ethereum. Builders were stoked, investors were keen. Life was good.
Cosmos offered something fresh, with its flexibility and interoperability, allowing developers to create custom solutions that could still communicate across its network while retaining critical sovereignty. The Cosmos SDK and Tendermint Core were game-changers, enabling rapid development and secure, scalable blockchains. But, some argue, all that amazing USP isn’t so unique any longer. The multichain thesis has proven itself and Ethereum, Solana, and other ecosystems are now playing the same game, adopting similar modular and interoperable approaches. Cosmos might have blazed the trail and proven the thesis, but the competition is heating up, pushing it to innovate further.
The silver lining, it’s still gold
While there are now other interoperable, modular, cross-chain upstarts who have joined the dance they all lack one critical, defining characteristic where Cosmos excels—sovereignty. At its core, sovereignty is what truly defines what blockchain represents, and it’s something Cosmos has embraced from the start. The emphasis on sovereignty, where each app chain can operate independently with its own governance and tokenomic models, is a unique advantage that Cosmos continues to offer. This isn’t just about technical capability—it’s about the philosophy of how blockchains should interact and relate to each other. For projects that prioritize autonomy and customization, Cosmos offers a level of control and flexibility that is difficult to find elsewhere. Sovereignty, combined with the industry-leading interoperability of IBC and the Cosmos SDK, gives Cosmos a serious competitive edge. But lately, that edge is getting muffled by a perfect storm—bear market blues, community infighting, and ambiguous leadership.
The elephant in the room – Addressing Governance and Community Challenges
At its heart, Cosmos is community and that community is broad and diverse – and often plagued with drama. Moreover, with the emphasis on chain sovereignty, Cosmos is actually a community of communities. The loose entanglement of Cosmos chains stands in contrast to what is seen in other crypto ecosystems. The nature of the meta community that is Cosmos means that it can be challenging to arrive at consensus, and that competition can impact incentive alignment. The problem extends beyond individuals and their loyalty to their native platforms, and includes the various foundations associated with individual chains, which often tend to their own gardens more than the broader Cosmos. One result of this dynamic is that the community has become overly reliant on the ICF, and their large coffers of ATOM, to drive forward the growth and evolution of Cosmos.
The ICF is currently being scrutinized with allegations of mismanagement, conflicts of interest, and a lack of transparency, leading to a decline in trust among many community members.
While these concerns are valid, they also present an opportunity for renewal. By embracing more transparent and inclusive governance practices, Cosmos can rebuild trust and strengthen its foundations. Greater community involvement in decision-making could help align the ecosystem’s direction with the needs and values of its stakeholders, ensuring that the leadership remains accountable and responsive. There is likewise, an opportunity for the various foundations working in Cosmos to step up and share some of the load that’s been placed on the ICF. This moment of introspection could be exactly what Cosmos needs to ensure it remains resilient in the face of challenges.
In addition to governance issues, there’s been a growing disconnect between developers and users within the Cosmos ecosystem. Developers, understandably focused on pushing the technical boundaries of what’s possible, sometimes place less emphasis on the practical needs of users. Interesting or novel technical solutions don’t always produce familiar and usable experiences for end users. This has led to slowed adoption, with users feeling sidelined or not adequately supported. Science experiments can be great, and certainly have their place, but aren’t a substitute for apps with good user experience and sensible product/market fit.
There’s a need to build stronger feedback loops where users can share their experiences, and developers can respond with solutions that address their concerns. By fostering a more user-centric approach, Cosmos can ensure that its innovations are not only technically advanced but also accessible and beneficial to the broader community. This alignment between development goals and user needs could help rebuild trust and engagement within the ecosystem.
Rediscovering the Original Vision
At its core, Cosmos was founded on a vision of decentralization and sovereignty—a vision that remains as relevant today as it was when the project first launched. People were initially drawn to Cosmos because it offered a way to create and connect independent blockchains without sacrificing the benefits of being part of a larger network. This vision of an interconnected, yet autonomous, network of blockchains continues to resonate with developers and users who value flexibility, innovation, and the potential for a truly decentralized internet of blockchains.
The original vision is something that the Cosmos community should reconnect with as it navigates its current challenges. The focus on sovereignty and interoperability is not just a technical approach; it’s a philosophy about how blockchain networks – and their communities – should function in the broader digital landscape. By recommitting to this vision, Cosmos can ensure that it remains true to its roots while continuing to innovate and evolve.
Community-driven initiatives, increased transparency, and a renewed focus on user needs can help realign the ecosystem with its foundational goals. By returning to its roots and emphasizing the principles of sovereignty, interoperability, and decentralization, Cosmos can continue to attract developers and users who share this vision. This is about more than just surviving in a competitive market—it’s about thriving by staying true to the values that made Cosmos successful in the first place.
A Future Full of Possibilities
Cosmos is undoubtedly at a pivotal moment in its development, however, this should not be seen as a crisis, but rather as an opportunity for growth and renewal. By addressing its governance challenges, improving communication and collaboration within the community, and continuing to innovate in response to competitive pressures, Cosmos can emerge stronger and more resilient. While the ecosystem has made significant strides, particularly in DeFi, there may be a risk of over-reliance on this sector. To ensure long-term resilience, it could benefit from fostering greater diversity in the types of projects being built. Exploring opportunities in decentralized identity, data management, and other innovative applications could reduce this dependency and drive broader adoption. The future of Cosmos holds equal promise today as it did when it first came to life, but it will require the active participation and support of its community. More bonding, support, collaboration, and focus on the shared vision—less complaining, negativity, and infighting. It’s about coming together to move forward by working together to overcome the current challenges and staying true to the original vision. Cosmos can continue to evolve and thrive, securing its place as a leader in the decentralized, multi-chain future.
# # #
Exciting News – DCF has launched a newsletter. Be the first to get all the latest news on what’s happening in the world of Decentralization, Agoric, Inter Protocol and more. Subscribe Now
# # #
Confused about what Decentralization really means for blockchain and crypto? Check out our blog post “Decentralization: Shouldn’t we finally agree on what it means?”